One Piece Chapter 1096 has reignited the age-old debate among fans about prime Garp versus Roger. This epic flashback has taken us back to the prime days of some of the series’ most iconic figures, and it’s hard not to wonder about what could have been if Garp had chosen a life of piracy.
Roger traveling around with a bunch of top tiers while Garp is bringing literal fodder to capture him💀
Give Garp a somewhat capable crew n Roger would be on the Marineford chopping block within 3-4 business days pic.twitter.com/OttA133KGO
— OnePeak (@OdasColorPages) October 26, 2023
One key argument that’s been circulating on social media is the support each of these great figures had in their respective careers. Roger was, without a doubt, backed by some of the strongest individuals in the world as part of his crew. On the other hand, Garp spent most of his career working alongside fellow Marine NPCs, with perhaps the exception of Bogard.
So, here’s the intriguing question: If Garp had been a pirate with a decent crew, could he have taken on and defeated Roger in the ultimate showdown?
Who would be on Garp’s Pirate Crew?
Before we jump into a showdown between Garp and Roger’s crews, let’s first consider who might join Garp’s hypothetical pirate crew. To keep it simple, we’ll focus on high-ranking Marines.
- First and foremost, Bogard is Garp’s loyal friend and would follow him anywhere, so his inclusion in Garp’s crew is a given.
- Kuzan also has a good chance of joining.
- Given that both Smoker and Fujitora have expressed disillusionment with the World Government, it’s likely they’d throw their lot in with Garp as well.
- While Magellan might not be the most enthusiastic recruit, his strong sense of justice could ultimately lead him to join the crew.
- We can also include Jaguar D. Saul and Vegapunk as potential additions to Garp’s pirate crew. Saul’s commitment to doing what’s right might lead him to become a member of Garp’s crew. As for Vegapunk, he already betrayed the WG once, and he might find a compelling reason to work with Garp in pursuit of justice and freedom.
Let’s assume that all of these powerful individuals do join Garp. With a crew boasting exceptional Devil Fruit abilities, it’s safe to say that the balance of power could shift a bit more in Garp’s favor, right?
Garp vs Roger: Would Garp win against Roger if he was a Pirate?
While it’s true that Roger himself once stated that Garp was his equal in strength, there are several factors to consider. It’s important to remember that Garp and Roger never engaged in a battle to inflict real damage. Roger’s main objective was always to escape, while Garp aimed to capture him. This dynamic could have influenced their interactions, making it hard to gauge their true relative strength.
- Additionally, it’s well-known that Whitebeard, the “Strongest Man in the World,” was the only one capable of going head-to-head with Roger, even when Roger was already ailing. This suggests that Garp, at his prime, might have been on par with Rayleigh, a formidable figure in his own right, but potentially not Roger’s equal.
The dynamics change significantly when we consider the addition of a hypothetical pirate crew led by Garp. Characters like Kuzan and Fujitora, with their powerful abilities, could deal significant damage to Roger’s crew. The likes of Saul and Vegapunk might destabilize the situation, while Magellan and Smoker could handle the finer details of the fights.
- However, in a hypothetical battle between these two crews, if the goal were to fight to the death, it’s plausible that Prime Garp’s crew might ultimately fall short against Roger’s. This isn’t to say they wouldn’t put up a fierce fight or inflict heavy damage. Yet, Roger and Rayleigh’s mastery of Haki alone might place them in a league above the others.
- While the Admirals are undoubtedly formidable, they may still be on par with the Yonko, (which is why we think they’d make unique Yonkos themselves). Roger, however, seems to be in a league of his own, transcending even the Yonko’s might.
This analysis is speculative, considering the limited information available about the older generation in One Piece. It’s an exciting debate, and we’d love to hear your thoughts on the matter in the comments. Do you think Garp had a real chance against Roger in a hypothetical clash of their prime crews?
Conclusion:
The hypothetical clash between Prime Garp and Gol D. Roger continues to be a source of fascination for fans. While Roger himself acknowledged Garp’s strength as his equal, the true extent of their power and how they might fare in a battle remains shrouded in mystery.
However, the ultimate question of whether Garp could have defeated Roger in his prime is a complex one. Roger’s mastery of Haki and his legendary status place him on a different level. What do you think? Let us know!
Meanwhile, discover the world of powerful shonen characters in our latest newsletter edition, spotlighting the incredible Gojo Satoru! If you enjoy our content, make sure to stay updated by subscribing to our newsletter. We release similar editions three times a week, so there’s always more to explore!
For more content, stay with us here at Spiel Times. Make sure you subscribe to our push notifications and never miss an update. You can also follow us on Spiel Anime, Twitter, Instagram, and YouTube. Until next time!
